How to Thrift Christmas and Hanukkah Gifts That Feel Meaningful (Not Cheap)
The holidays can be one of the most joyful — and expensive — times of the year. Between gifts, décor, and all the festivities, it’s easy for costs to add up fast. But what if I told you that some of the most meaningful gifts you’ll ever give don’t have to cost much at all?
That’s the idea behind Thriftmas — focusing more on meaning and less on spending. Whether you’re celebrating Christmas, Hanukkah, or both, thrifting your gifts is not only budget-friendly but also creative, sustainable, and fun.
Here’s how to make it work — and actually enjoy the process.
1. Start With a Gift List
Before you head to the thrift store, make a list of who you’re shopping for and a few gift ideas for each person. It helps you stay focused so you’re not wandering aimlessly down every aisle.
Think about each person’s personality, hobbies, or home style — are they cozy and sentimental, minimal and modern, a gardener, or a homebody? This will help you spot the perfect item when you see it.
✨ Pro Tip: Download my free Thriftmas Gift Guide below! It’s a printable checklist that breaks down gift ideas for everyone — from moms and dads to teachers and kids — plus simple DIY tips for each category to make your thrifted gifts extra special.
👉 [Download the Thriftmas Gift Guide]
2. Look for Items You Can Personalize
Thrifted gifts feel special when you make them yours.
Here are a few ideas that work beautifully for both Christmas and Hanukkah gifting:
Picture frames – Add a meaningful photo or a small piece of art.
Baskets or trays – Use them as “gift bases” for treats, spa items, or candles.
Glass jars or bottles – Fill with homemade bubble bath, flavored oils, or cocoa mix.
Mugs or pottery – Pair with tea, coffee, or a handwritten note.
When you add a personal touch, the gift feels thoughtful — not thrifted.
3. Think Beyond the Obvious
Thrift stores are treasure hunts. Look beyond what an item is and think about what it could be.
A vintage bowl could become a beautiful planter.
A brass tray could hold candles or jewelry.
A small basket could be filled with snacks for a teacher or neighbor.
Creativity is what makes thrifting gifts so rewarding — you’re giving something unique that no one else will find on a store shelf.
4. Keep an Eye Out for “New with Tags” or “In Box” Items
Many thrift stores receive donations of brand-new or unused items — especially around the holidays. These make amazing gifts for anyone who prefers something fresh and unopened. Check electronics sections, books, toys, and home décor aisles.
5. Bundle Small Finds Into Themed Gifts
Thrifting isn’t just about one big find — sometimes it’s about curating little ones into something special.
Here are a few bundle ideas:
The Cozy Night In – thrifted mug + blanket + cocoa + candle
The Home Spa Kit – basket + bath salts + thrifted jar + loofah
The Gardener’s Gift – vintage pot + seed packets + gloves
The Hanukkah Host Gift – thrifted tray + candles + small treats
Bundling makes your thrifted finds feel intentional and elevated.
6. Don’t Forget the Presentation
Wrap thrifted gifts beautifully — a little effort goes a long way. Use:
Brown kraft paper tied with ribbon or twine
Fabric wraps or scarves (bonus gift!)
Vintage tins or baskets instead of boxes
Presentation is what transforms a thrifted find into something truly special.
7. Give Yourself Time
Thrifting takes a bit more patience than traditional shopping, so start early. You might not find everything in one trip — but that’s part of the fun. When you go in with an open mind (and maybe a warm coffee in hand), it feels like a mini treasure hunt.
The Heart of Thriftmas
Whether you’re gifting for Christmas or Hanukkah, thrifting isn’t about giving something secondhand — it’s about giving something thoughtful. Each piece has a story, and when you add your own touch, that story becomes part of the gift.
So this year, skip the big-box stress and see what treasures you can find at your local thrift store. You might be surprised at how meaningful, affordable, and creative your holiday gifting can be.
